Netflix, Disney, and the State of Paid Subscription Sharing
At the end of 2023, when Netflix reported eye-popping profits from its widely publicized crackdown on subscription-sharing and the surcharge sharers would henceforth have to pay, concerns arose around the industry that other subscription streaming services from premium to niche would soon be following suit and restricting the common practice of subscription sharing with their user base.
In this candid debate from February’s Streaming Media Connect 2024, Evan Shapiro, CEO, ESHAP, Alan Wolk, Co-Founder/Lead Analyst, TVREV, and Jon Giegengack, Principal and Founder, Hub Entertainment Research, discuss who’s cracking down and how much they’re enforcing the new restriction, and what if any benefit smaller-market services are likely to gain from following Netflix’s lead.
During the Q&A portion of the session, Shapiro read a question from a viewer: “Many others are following Netflix into page sharing as it showed great success for Netflix. Do you know who else is going in the same way?”
Shapiro says, “I'm going to toss this to Alan [Wolk], who is to me all things streaming, or to Jon [Giegengack], who tracks this subscription stuff pretty well, but I know Disney started to crack down.”
Wolk says, “They're all kind of doing it and kind of not. The thing is, they'll send emails here and there. They'll ask you to re-authenticate, but they're not telling people, ‘No more TV for you if you don't get a new account.’ They've been relying on threatening emails, and they all test it out in other places, but no one, not even Netflix, has rolled it out all across the board.”
Giegengack says that most smaller platforms have much more to lose than Netflix if they also crack down on account sharing significantly, whereas Netflix has the market dominance to truly take the chance of alienating users. “Netflix has replaced the old cable TV as the default thing people watch,” he says. “There's something on there for everybody. But I think if it's more of a niche, will you be willing to pay extra just to keep getting Paramount Plus because you really want to watch the Taylor Sheridan shows while they're still on?” He says that Netflix’s sheer scale protects it and allows it to call out people’s bluff, whereas that approach is much riskier for most other platforms. He mentions a viable alternative. “The way to generate more revenue would be to do what Disney Plus did when they launched and give you a deal on the price if you subscribe for a certain amount of time. I think that might be a better route for some of these platforms than really cracking down hard on password sharing.”
Shapiro says, “But doesn’t it seem to have worked incredibly well for Netflix? I mean, am I missing something?”
Wolk says it is simply a matter of Netflix having more runway to take a harder stance on subscription sharing. He argues that raising the price of ad-free versions to push users towards ad-supported options, following Amazon's successful model, may be inevitable. “They all got blindsided by Amazon, who basically came in and said, ‘Yeah, everybody's ad-supported now.' And we're estimating that’s somewhere between 50 to 65 million people. So they've got to catch up.”
Read Part One of our recap of Evan Shapiro’s Streaming Media Connect 2024 opening keynote, “No Quarter—Separating Fact From Fiction in M&E Q4 Earnings Reports.”
View full sessions from February's Streaming Media Connect 2024.
We'll be back in person for Streaming Media NYC on May 20-22, 2024. More details here.
Related Articles
In a U.S. market first, Capital One has partnered with Minna Technologies to offer new subscription management tools directly in the bank's mobile app, enabling its credit card customers to view and manage subscriptions from major merchants, including leading streaming media, publishing and retail brands.
24 Oct 2024
Following in the footsteps of Netflix and Max, Disney+ is the latest streamer to crackdown on account sharing to boost subscriber growth and keep the business viable.
10 Apr 2024
With 4Q earnings calls putting a bow on 2023, M&E industry cartographer Evan Shapiro pulls no punches in this real-time response, digging deep into the data to hold the spin doctors accountable, giving Streaming Media Connect attendees an unvarnished view of the industry that they won't get anywhere else. Read Part Two of our recap of Shapiro's Q4 keynote earnings analysis from Streaming Media Connect 2024.
05 Mar 2024
Major media and entertainment companies' quarterly earnings calls ought to pull back the curtain on what's really happening in the industry, but they routinely bury unflattering numbers in expert spin, and the press on hand rarely asks questions tough enough to draw out the real story. With 4Q earnings calls putting a bow on 2023, M&E industry cartographer Evan Shapiro pulls no punches in this real-time response, digging deep into the data to hold the spin doctors accountable, giving Streaming Media Connect attendees an unvarnished view of the industry that they won't get anywhere else.
27 Feb 2024
When it comes to consumers' evolving viewing preferences and the pitch and yaw of streaming monetization, will we ever see a clear winner between advertising-based and subscription services when it comes to OTT and streaming content delivery and consumption? Philo Head of Advertising Reed Barker and Norsk CMO Eric Schumacher-Rasmussen discuss in this clip from their Streaming Media East 2023 keynote.
12 Jul 2023
Jon Giegengack of Hub Entertainment Research talks about shifting SVOD strategies with Tim Siglin in this exclusive interview from Streaming Media East 2023.
23 Jun 2023