Why Hybrid Events Aren't Working
Hybrid events have become much more common since the pandemic, but they have not proven to be as effective or engaging as in-person events. What are some of the issues that prevent the best QoE for hybrid participants, and how can they be remedied? Chris Pfaff, CEO, Chris Pfaff Tech Media, Producers Guild of America (PGA), VR AR Association (VRARA), discusses these issues with Alex Lindsay, Head of Operations, 090 Media, and Dan Houze, VP, Encoding & Digital Strategy, BC Live in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2023.
Chris Pfaff begins by pointing out that it was not too long ago that streamed live events were audio-only, and that it was only just before the pandemic that video began to be widely incorporated into the experience for virtual audiences. The pandemic accelerated the process of developing higher-quality streaming video at scale. However, even with the leap of improvements for QoE, much remains left to be desired. “I think for any event that you're talking about, whether it's a corporate event [or] a concert, that's a huge issue,” he says. “So I really want to start with that as a topic because when we're all involved in these events, I think we're very forgiving. But you know, scale is such a huge part of this.” He asks Alex Lindsay of 090 Media, “What's your take on how far we've come in terms of really getting that quality experience and that scale?”
“I think we're starting to get there,” Lindsay says. “[But] I think we're sliding backward a little bit. You know, now people want to come back into the room, and I think that the ways we're coming back into the room have been sliding us back into the 2015, 2016 range.” He laughs and says, “You know, I've been doing this a bit longer than many people…”
“We can tell by the gear behind you!” Pfaff says.
“2008, 2009 is when we really started streaming video,” Lindsay says. “And the main thing is that we aren't doing it that much better now in some cases when we go back to physical events.” He refers to webinars such as Streaming Media Connect, “A lot of these events are starting to work. The problem is that there's data that we have from 10 years ago that told us that the hybrid events weren't working, and they're still not working.”
Pfaff says, “So as an adjunct, that you're a second-class citizen if you're not in the room, you should be happy that there's a camera with a terrible angle of five people on a stage. Is that what we're talking about?”
“Yeah,” Lindsay says. “When we started, it made sense. You know, we're streaming Dreamforce, and there's 15,000 people in the room and 300 people watching, you are second class…”
“For those who don't know, Dreamforce is Salesforce,” Pfaff says. “It’s Salesforce’s mondo over-the-top annual event.”
Lindsay emphasizes that the core issue is a virtual audience’s sense of not being fully connected to a live event, which ultimately colors their perception of the event’s significance. In that situation, he says, “They don’t feel like the event's important. They don't feel like the product is important. They don't feel like a lot of these things are important, and we don't talk enough [about that].”
“So you’re saying that in some respect, there's a brand disconnect?” Pfaff says. That you're damaging your brand to some extent?”
Lindsay notes that not only does this sense of disconnect damage the brand, but it hampers enthusiasm for virtual participants to return to the event. “It's the most devastating way to do this because they don't complain,” he says. “People who complain care about the event, they want it to be better. People who don't complain oftentimes are just disappearing. We've called them and said, ‘Hey, why didn't you come?’ ‘Well, I was just busy.’ You know, it wasn't like ‘I'm mad that I felt like I was in the back of the room…’”
Pfaff points out that accessibility is also a critical issue that does not get enough attention. He asks Dan Houze of BC Live about his insights into audience accessibility, not just for digital-first events like webinars but particularly for hybrid events.
Houze narrows the accessibility issue down to consumer versus internal audiences. “I think that a lot of times the virtual shows we're doing, or the hybrid shows or digital-first shows that we're doing are sort of just corporate-driven and they're sort of internal meetings,” he says. “It's not necessarily launching a keynote for a new product or something like that.”
Lindsay agrees but contends that engagement matters no matter what the type of hybrid event, even corporate ones. “You still have to keep all the employees going in the same direction,” he says. “When you create an event where they don't feel important, you're not getting quite the same charge out of your corporate event.”
Learn more about hybrid events at Streaming Media East 2023.
Related Articles
As streaming has moved through the pandemic years into a new normal that isn't exactly what anyone expected, the meaning of hybrid event streaming production and delivery that has emerged over the last few years continues to evolve. So what does it mean in 2023, for producers, organizations, and audiences, both onsite and remote? And what can streamers do to level the playing field for those participating from near and far? In this clip from their recent panel at Streaming Media Connect 2023, LiveX's Anna Cowdery, Ohio State's Derrick Freeman, Boston 25 News's Ben Ratner, Stream4us' Anthony Burokas, and Howard & Associates' Andy Howard discuss best definitions and best practices for hybrid event video in 2023.
20 Sep 2023
What are hybrid streaming environments and how do large-scale streamers and broadcasters manage workloads and divide tasks between cloud and on-prem infrastructure? Microsoft's Andy Beach and TV2's Loke Dupont discuss distribution strategies in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2023.
05 May 2023
The biggest problem with hybrid events is focusing entirely on the on-site audience treating the online/digital audience like an afterthought. 090 Media's Alex Lindsay, who's been producing virtual and hybrid events since well before the pandemic, and Social180Group's John Porterfield provide indispensable tips on how to avoid falling into that trap, and fully integrating digital audiences into the event experience in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2023.
28 Apr 2023
With so many virtual event platforms available today, which one is right for your events? 090 Media's Alex Lindsay and BC Live's Dan Houze pull no punches when assessing what the current crop of platforms get wrong, how they can do it better, and how to avoid the common pitfalls of producing virtual and hybrid events that don't pass muster in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2023.
10 Apr 2023
The demand for internal and external virtual meetings and events in the enterprise has grown exponentially in the last three years. How can streaming service and platform providers help enterprises navigate their options and manage costs and expectations? Experts from LinkedIn and EY offer key insights from their panel at Streaming Media Connect 2023.
29 Mar 2023
LinkedIn's Dan Swiney and Lockheed Martin's Eric Hards discuss how their organizations' approach to events and internal meetings has evolved since the pandemic's start in this panel from Streaming Media West 2022.
17 Feb 2023
090 Media's Alex Lindsay discusses the challenges of engaging remote streaming audiences with hybrid events and the advantages of digital-first productions in this clip from Streaming Media West 2022.
16 Jan 2023
Microsoft's Andy Beach and LiveX's Corey Behnke discuss best practices for delivering effective hybrid and virtual events using streaming technology in this clip from Streaming Media West 2022.
11 Jan 2023
Hosting a successful hybrid event means understanding how to create the best virtual and in-person event strategy while ensuring that event organizers prepare for all possible variables.
24 Aug 2022
With its lightning-quick action and intense high-motion graphics, livestreamed esports presents unique encoding challenges for outfits like Activision Blizzard that need to delivery top-quality streams to mass gaming audiences all the time. In this clip from Streaming Media Connect, Blizzard's Corey Smith explains how they do it and what they prioritize along the way.
29 Mar 2022
Streaming Learning Center's Jan Ozer explains how Netflix's shot-based works and explains its benefits in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media Connect 2021.
12 Mar 2021